Citrola's Italian Restaurant on McGregor

Cyndy Miller 2 months ago

I would like to take a moment to mention the staff. I'm a lady who dined alone one evening, recently & I had the best time! All of the girls working that evening, we're so welcoming and happy. Ava, was my server. She was as superb as my Shrimp Alfredo! I felt so cared for, (by everyone!!!) Ava was spot on, attentive and kind. This is an amazing staff. They were all happy and all working together, it was obvious they love their job. I was so delighted with my visit, on my way out, I asked if I may speak to the owner. The girls explained that the owner was not there. Kudos to her staff for representing 100 % !!! So impressive. I will be back with my friends for another visit this week!!!! Thanks girls!!!! Sincerely, Cyndy 🥰💯👍

Eric Starner 3 months ago

Love eating here when we are in town. There pizza is the best. Just watch your bill they will add a service fee for paying cash.

Annie Barlum 3 months ago

Citrola’s Italian Restaurant is the real deal. Seriously, the aroma of garlic and simmering sauce literally warms the entire neighborhood, and you can smell the magic right from the street as you approach. The vibe inside is fantastic, but word to the wise, get here early because the tables fill up fast and for good reason. The food is pure, comforting heaven. My husband ordered the spaghetti and meatballs and immediately declared that the meatballs tasted 100% homemade. They have that authentic, rich flavor that takes us right back to the incredible Italian cooking we grew up around in Detroit. We are not Italian ourselves, but we know the good stuff when we taste it. As for my lasagna, it was spectacular. It was loaded with cheese, perfectly saucy, and easily gives the high end Italian spots back home a serious run for their money. Our server was top notch, super friendly and attentive without hovering. To top it all off, the portions are so massive that we walked out with a heavy box of leftovers. They went straight into our hotel mini fridge and became the ultimate late night snack the next evening. Honestly, it tasted just as wonderful the second time around. If you want a phe

Ciara Gaugh 4 months ago

This is by far the best italian restaurant in the area! Our family and friends are never disappointed when dining with Citrolas! The staff is friendly and very knowledgeable about the menu. The food is affordable and absolutely amazing! The atmosphere is so comfortable and family friendly. We feel a part of the family here and honestly I cannot think of another restaurant that we recommend more than Citrolas! Try it out, you will NOT be disappointed!

SWFL Broker Greg Demaras 4 months ago

Spectacular local Italian home cooking restaurant! Probably the best garlic knots I’ve ever had! Everything else is exceptional as well. Worth a visit!

Dave Philpott 5 months ago

Three visits in and this place keeps delivering great Italian food. I’ve had the Chicken Piccata, Spaghetti with Meatballs, and Spaghetti with Sausage - all classics done right, and honestly some of the best versions of those dishes I’ve found at any Italian restaurant. Worth noting: I drove over from Sanibel. Prices are reasonable, and while it’s not upscale dining, it’s a perfect spot for families and groups who want a solid, satisfying meal without a big bill at the end. Four stars on service only because they forgot my water when I was waiting for a takeout order - minor, but worth mentioning.​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Melissa G. 7 months ago

Very nicely decorated restaurant, Ashley was very nice and efficient. We had the lobster 🦞 ravioli, the bread was very good. The prices were reasonable and the food is very good. The restaurant and restrooms were very clean.

George Sharrard 2 years ago

The food is so good we ate here two nights in a row. The eggplant Parm is the best. Very nice people. Had a real family feel to it. Wine list was OK. Good size parking lot too